Franchise Disclosure Document for Dummies – Part 6
In part six of this series on understanding the FDD, we continue on with Items 15 and 16. Item 15 discloses franchisees’ operational obligations and limitations, and Item 16 covers limitations on the products and services that franchisees can offer for sales.
Items 15 and 16 are two of the shorter Items in the Franchise Disclosure Document. However, they – and Item 15 in particular – still contain critical information for prospective franchisees to consider evaluating potential franchise opportunities.
Item 15 – Obligation to Participate in the Actual Operation of the Franchised Business
The key disclosure in Item 15 states whether the franchise owner is obligated to participate in the direct operations of the franchised business. For prospective franchisees looking for a pure investment rather than a business opportunity, this disclosure might be the first (and only) provision they read in the FDD. Although, an experienced franchise investor may be able to negotiate an exception with the franchisor.
Other Item 15 disclosures include:
- If participation is not required, whether or not it is recommended
- Any mandatory limitations for franchisees’ on-premises managers and supervisors (such as training obligations, confidentiality agreements and non-competition covenants)
- Any requirement for the franchisee’s managers or supervisors to own an equity interest in the franchise
While often overlooked, this final issue can be an important one for both franchisors and franchisees. By requiring day-to-day managers to literally buy-in to the franchise, franchisors and franchisees can help make sure that these essential personnel have an incentive to help grow the business instead of merely showing up to collect a paycheck.
Item 16 – Restrictions on what the Franchisee may Sell
Item 16 contains fairly straight-forward disclosures, including:
- Whether franchisees may only sell franchisor-approved goods/services
- Whether franchisees must sell all franchisor-approved goods/services
- Whether the franchisor reserves the right to modify the list of approved goods/services (it should)
For service-based franchises, the franchisor will almost always limit the scope of services franchisees can offer, as the service offering will often be the underlying concept for the entire franchise system. For restaurants and other product-based franchises, depending on the franchisor’s concept (and depending on whether the franchisor itself sells products to franchisees), the franchisor may limit franchisees’ sourcing options, or it may grant some leeway—subject to inspection, standards compliance, etc.—to use substitute or local products and suppliers.
Next week’s installment will focus on Items 17, 18 and 19 of the FDD, which cover the franchise agreement, use of public figures to promote the franchise, and financial performance representations.
Jeff Fabian is the owner of Fabian, LLC, a boutique intellectual property and business law firm serving new and established franchisors and prospective franchisees. Contact the firm directly at 410.908.0883 or email@example.com. You can also follow Jeff on Twitter @jsfabian.
This article is provided for informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult an attorney before taking any action that may affect your legal rights or liabilities.
Quantifying Yelp's Impact on the Restaurant Industry
Luca studied the effects of Yelp ratings on the revenue of restaurants and discovered several interesting findings. Studying the relationships of restaurants' revenues to their Yelp reviews in Seattle over a period from 2003 to 2009, he found a significant relationship between a restaurant’s average rating and revenue. One star’s worth of improvement on Yelp leads, he found, on average to an increase of between 5 and 9 percent in revenue. The average rating is more important than the review, as many Yelp users are overwhelmed by the sheer number of reviews on manyrestaurantpages and find it easier to consult the star rating. Luca also found two features which exacerbate the effect on revenue Yelp has. First, the more reviews a restaurant has, the more impact an increase in its Yelp rating will have on its revenue. Second, the more reviews by Yelp “elite” members, the more impact; “elite” reviews have almost twice as much impact as other reviews.
Why I Have an Issue with the Forbes Franchise Rankings
The 5-Year Growth Rate and 5-Year Franchise Continuity are both great independent metrics of how a franchise is doing on average. As a potential franchisee both of these statistics are vital for selecting a franchise - you want to select a franchise that will provide you with a high return on investment and which will survive in the long run. I think these are, as FRANdata and Forbes suggested, two of the biggest (if not the two biggest) and most obvious metrics for whether or not a franchise is a “good” opportunity for a franchisee. But how do you use these to determine which franchise is BEST? This is the fundamental difficulty in coming up with a ranking system - it isn’t the difficulty in separating the good from the meh from the bad - it’s separating the great from the good and the best from the great. In the case of these rankings I found it to be pretty difficult to comprehend how they differentiated between the top ranked franchises. For instance, if you look at the difference between Discover Map (Forbes #4), Just Between Friends (Forbes #5), & Seniors Helping Seniors (Forbes #6) they all have extremely close continuity ratings and substantially different growth rates. In fact, in the case of these three, the overall rankings are opposite the growth rate rankings. Seniors Helping Seniors is ranked at the bottom of these three franchises despite having a growth rate that is 31 percentage points higher than Discovery Map and a continuity that is only 2 percentage points lower. This suggested to me that continuity was viewed as the dominant factor. But that logic didn’t hold for the rest on the “Economy Class” Top 10, as BrightStar Care (Forbes #7) had the same growth rate as Pop-a-Lock (Forbes #8) but a continuity rate that was 12 percentage points lower. These comparisons show that these were not the only two factors that went into the rankings, which is understandable, but no other factors that are explicitly listed in their results seem to be major factors.
How to Read the Franchise Disclosure Document and Red Flags to Look For
This webinar is designed to help you learn how to choose a franchise wisely. Your selection process should consist of thorough research, analysis, and focused investigation. Understanding how to properly read and analyze the franchisor's required documentation, the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD), is one of the most important activities you will perform in your franchise selection process.