Franchises and Business Opportunities – Understanding the Difference
For entrepreneurs seeking to hit the ground running with a new business venture, there are two main categories of opportunities out there that allow them to benefit from the experience, assets and reputation of existing business concepts. These are: (i) the franchise, and (ii) the “business opportunity”.
While they're often referred to in tandem (and the terms are occasionally used interchangeably), there are in fact important, fundamental differences between franchises and business opportunities. This article identifies those differences and highlights some of the benefits and drawbacks of both unique business concepts.
What is a Franchise?
As defined by federal law, a “franchise” is a business relationship in which one company (the franchisor) grants another independent business owner (the franchisee):
(i) The right to use the franchisor’s trademark and brand to identify and promote a business, and
(ii) The right (and obligation) to operate that business according to the franchisor’s proprietary system, guidelines and control, where
(iii) The grant is conditioned upon an initial payment of at least $500.00 within the first 6 months of the franchisee’s business operations.
If these 3 elements are present, then the business relationship is a franchise, and the franchisor must comply with all federal and state laws governing the offering and sale of franchises. In addition, many states have “relationship” laws which provide protections to franchisees once the franchise agreement is signed.
Most franchise opportunities are designed as long-term (commonly, 10-year-plus) relationships, and are governed by detailed and heavy-handed franchise agreements. Most franchise systems also have detailed Operations Manuals which become binding on franchisees and further describe the franchisees’ operational rights and obligations.
What is a “Business Opportunity”?
Generally speaking, a business opportunity consists of a marketing plan, training program and/or pre-arranged collection of goods or services that the opportunity seller offers to aspiring entrepreneurs for purposes of allowing the entrepreneurs to go into business for themselves. As compared to franchises, business opportunities often have much lower initial fees, and generally do not entail ongoing royalty payments. The buyer is free to market under its own trademark and business system, and the seller has no ongoing obligations to the buyer. Thus, once the business opportunity is sold, that is generally the end of the parties’ formal relationship.
Business opportunities are not regulated on the federal level. Many states have registration requirements for business opportunities, though the conditions for registration are typically minimal.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Franchises:
There are numerous potential benefits and drawbacks to purchasing a franchise. Some of these include:
- Potential Benefits:
- Long-term relationship with contract-mandated support structure
- Instant brand recognition and good will from the franchisor’s trademarks
- Protection under federal and state laws governing franchise sales and franchisor-franchisee relations
- With established franchisors, tried-and-true business systems with a proven record of success given the right conditions and management
- Potential Drawbacks:
- Long-term, binding relationship, often with little opportunity for exiting and the potential for ongoing payment obligations even after termination
- Generally higher initial fees plus ongoing royalty and advertising fund obligations, even after the business becomes self-sufficient
- Potentially limited growth opportunity, depending on territorial rights of other franchisees and the cost to purchase additional franchise territories
Benefits and Drawbacks of Business Opportunities:
Business opportunities have benefits and drawbacks as well:
- Potential Benefits:
- Lower initial cost as compared to franchises
- No binding commitment to the seller
- Freedom to operate under own business name and business system
- Potential Drawbacks:
- Limited (if any) support from the seller
- No affiliation with track-tested trademark or proven business system
- Revenue potential and margins are often limited
- SCAMS, SCAMS, SCAMS: Many “business opportunities” are scams, and prospective buyers need to be careful to do their homework before making a commitment
All in all, franchises and business opportunities are two very different animals. Both can represent legitimate opportunities for entrepreneurs, but both also entail their own respective sets of risks and concerns. Before committing to any franchise or business opportunity, it is crucial for the prospective buyer to perform the necessary due diligence and market research to make sure that the opportunity—whichever they may choose—has a realistic chance for success in their chosen market.
Jeff Fabian is the owner of Fabian, LLC, a boutique intellectual property and business law firm serving new and established franchisors and prospective franchisees. Contact the firm directly at 410.908.0883 or email@example.com. You can also follow Jeff on Twitter @jsfabian.
This article is provided for informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult an attorney before taking any action that may affect your legal rights or liabilities.
Why I Have an Issue with the Forbes Franchise Rankings
The 5-Year Growth Rate and 5-Year Franchise Continuity are both great independent metrics of how a franchise is doing on average. As a potential franchisee both of these statistics are vital for selecting a franchise - you want to select a franchise that will provide you with a high return on investment and which will survive in the long run. I think these are, as FRANdata and Forbes suggested, two of the biggest (if not the two biggest) and most obvious metrics for whether or not a franchise is a “good” opportunity for a franchisee. But how do you use these to determine which franchise is BEST? This is the fundamental difficulty in coming up with a ranking system - it isn’t the difficulty in separating the good from the meh from the bad - it’s separating the great from the good and the best from the great. In the case of these rankings I found it to be pretty difficult to comprehend how they differentiated between the top ranked franchises. For instance, if you look at the difference between Discover Map (Forbes #4), Just Between Friends (Forbes #5), & Seniors Helping Seniors (Forbes #6) they all have extremely close continuity ratings and substantially different growth rates. In fact, in the case of these three, the overall rankings are opposite the growth rate rankings. Seniors Helping Seniors is ranked at the bottom of these three franchises despite having a growth rate that is 31 percentage points higher than Discovery Map and a continuity that is only 2 percentage points lower. This suggested to me that continuity was viewed as the dominant factor. But that logic didn’t hold for the rest on the “Economy Class” Top 10, as BrightStar Care (Forbes #7) had the same growth rate as Pop-a-Lock (Forbes #8) but a continuity rate that was 12 percentage points lower. These comparisons show that these were not the only two factors that went into the rankings, which is understandable, but no other factors that are explicitly listed in their results seem to be major factors.
Profiling the Best Burger Chains in America
Once upon a time, Americans had two options to alleviate their beef binging desires: visit a fast food jointor go to a traditionalsit-down restaurant. The former often offered sub-par meals, while the latter required too much of a commitment of both time and money. The people demanded a happy medium, where they could be chowing down on quality eats within minutes of ordering.
Follow the System
While these franchisees might think they are helping the brand, in fact it’s just the opposite.