Steps to Select and Protect a Valuable Trademark
My previous post on this site discussed considerations for developing a franchise system, which included establishing a strong brand identity. This article discusses some key considerations for developing a valuable brand from a legal perspective, including: selecting a protectable trademark, making sure the trademark is available, and registering and enforcing your trademark rights.
Selecting a Protectable Trademark
The first thing to keep in mind when selecting a trademark is that not all words and names are capable of being protected as trademarks. No one business owner can claim exclusive rights in generic terms and logos, because all business owners need to be able to use these in order to identify their goods or services. Thus, a residential painting franchise likely could not claim exclusive rights in the name “Painting Pros”, because this is simply a generic description of the services that the business offers.
There is actually a scale for types of trademarks and the levels of protection they can obtain:
- Generic – not subject to trademark protection
- Descriptive (describes the goods/services as opposed to merely stating what they are) – protectable as a trademark only after acquiring “secondary meaning” (recognition) in the relevant marketplace
- Suggestive (slightly more cerebral than descriptive, but still identifies the goods/services on its face—think Facebook) – protectable
- Arbitrary (think Apple for computers) – protectable, and subject to a greater scope of protection than suggestive marks
- Fanciful (made up words) – afforded the greatest scope of protection
The trend these days seems to be to tend more toward suggestive trademarks, as they provide exclusivity while also identifying the nature of the business. However, many franchise companies have found great success with arbitrary and fanciful trademarks, and these types of brand names are often more memorable once consumers become aware of the brand.
Making Sure Your Trademark Is Available
After coming up with an idea for a protectable trademark, the next step is to make sure that the trademark is available for use. This is a time-intensive, research-intensive process that is best left to the professionals. In certain circumstances this “clearance” research will conclusively establish that another business has already acquired exclusive rights in your proposed trademark; in others, it will establish with a reasonable degree of confidence that the mark is available for adoption; and, in others still, it will result in a level of uncertainty that requires a strategic decision on whether or not to pursue the desired trademark.
The basic principle underlying the need to conduct trademark clearance research is that, under U.S. law, brand owners have the ability to acquire exclusive rights in the trademarks they adopt to identify their goods or services in the marketplace. If ABC, Inc. is using your proposed trademark for its custom blind franchise, you will (making certain assumptions about the nature of the mark and the status of ABC, Inc.’s ownership) be prohibited from adopting the same trademark for your blind installation franchise concept.
Another important issue relates to the fact that brand owners can obtain geographically-limited “common law” rights even if they do not apply for federal registration with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”). This issue is of particular concern for franchisors seeking to expand on a regional or national scale. These common law rights preempt the exclusive rights obtained through any subsequent federal registration. Thus, if a five-store restaurant chain in California is already using your proposed trademark, even if you obtain a federal registration, that restaurant chain may still be able to prevent you from selling franchises in California under your new trademark.
Applying for Trademark Registration
Once you determine that your trademark is available, as suggested above, the next step is to apply for registration with the USPTO. Subject to any pre- existing common law rights, registration with the USPTO provides the trademark owner with exclusive rights nationwide to make use of the mark. Readers familiar with the Franchise Disclosure Document (“FDD”) will recall that Item 12 of the FDD requires specific disclosures relating to the registration status of the franchisor’s trademarks. If the franchisor’s trademark is not yet registered, this must be disclosed in the FDD, and this can be a key factor for prospective franchisees who are trying to decide between competing franchise opportunities. Thus, companies considering franchising would be well advised to seek registration for their trademarks early in the process, if not sooner for their own internal business purposes.
Enforcing Your Trademark Rights
Finally, once registration is obtained, franchisors and other trademark owners need to take steps to proactively monitor and enforce their trademark rights. This can include regular monitoring of social media sites and online databases, franchisee audits, and other tasks to spot infringement and correct improper uses. Like clearance research, trademark monitoring is a task best left to the pros. If an infringer is discovered, swift action should be taken to enforce the franchisor’s exclusive rights. Failure to enforce trademark rights can lead to abandonment, and then the business is back to square one.
By following these general guidelines, business owners can help maximize the value and leveragability of their trademarks. This is of particular interest for aspiring franchisors, as a strong trademark can help make or break a new franchise concept. In the long run, the relatively modest expenses of selecting and protecting a valuable trademark will be far surpassed by the benefits that a strong trademark can provide.
Jeff Fabian is the owner of Fabian, LLC, a boutique intellectual property and business law firm serving new and established franchisors and franchisees. Contact the firm directly at 410.908.0883 or firstname.lastname@example.org. You can also follow Jeff on Twitter @jsfabian.
This article is provided for informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult an attorney before taking any action that may affect your legal rights or liabilities.
Best Practices in Protecting and Enforcing Trademarks, Copyrights and other IP
Trademarks, copyrighted works, trade secrets and proprietary business information form the core of any franchise system, and are frequently a company’s most valuable assets. Trademarks, including service marks, logos, slogans and trade dress, define the brand identity as presented to the public. The “behind the scenes” business know-how on which the system is built and implemented by franchisees is embodied in a variety of copyrighted and proprietary works – operations manuals, proprietary processes, recipes and formulas, custom software, advertising copy to name a few.
Franchisee Insight: Learning from Franchisor Litigation (or Lack Thereof)
The Item 3 disclosure requirements are complex compared to other items of the FDD, but they can generally be summarized as follows. In Item 3, franchisors must disclose: